Miscellaneous - July 2009
by Benjamin Howarth
published: 24 / 6 / 2009

intro
In his latest 'Condemned to Rock 'n' Rols' column, Ben Howarth asks if Michael Jackson was any good musically
Here’s a question I’ve never found a need to ask myself before: Was Michael Jackson any good? Hmmm… As a student, I occasionally allowed myself to attend student club nights, where a leading light in the student union would offer up an entirely tasteless selection of chart pop, not-quite-hip-hop, 90s-nostalgia and then some music I liked even less than that. In between, ‘Billie Jean’ sounded simply magnificent. But buying a copy for myself, to listen to in my own home? Perhaps he was better than I give him credit for. It is true that he had sold an awful lot of records. Just not to me. Writing in 'The Guardian' earlier this month, art critic Jonathan Jones argued that the reason he had become a success in his line of work was that, “I know that my instinct for what is valuable in art is unusually sure”. Mr Jones knows best. He insisted that criticism wasn’t democratic, and that the public needed him to tell them what wasn‘t good. Had he turned his hand to reviewing pop records, I’d like to know what Jonathan Jones would have made of Michael Jackson. Critics have always had a difficult time with him. And that hasn’t made any difference at all, as ‘Thriller’ has sold more copies than just about anything else, while musicians and the public continue to revere him not just as entertaining, but a master of his craft. 'Q' magazine rather unfortunately decided to make a less than complementary feature on Jackson their cover story the month before he died. Yet, in 1999 he was not included at all in a list of “the 100 greatest stars of the 20th century”, a list that did manage to make room for Bez, the dancer from the Happy Mondays, one of the very worst bands ever. Even their readership wasn’t overwhelmed, as in 2006, ‘Thriller’ only secured enough votes to come in at 58 in a list of their favourite albums. Their more reverential sister-paper, 'Mojo', meanwhile, wasn’t even that generous. Not one of his songs made their list of the greatest songs of all time, nor could he make their list of 100 greatest singers or greatest albums. But the public carried on buying ‘Thriller’ regardless, and now that he’s dead, everyone seems to have decided - without pausing for thought - that Jackson was a towering cultural figure, the Elvis of his times. After all, the public voted with their feet. But, by that logic, 'Titanic' would be a cinematic achievement to rank alongside 'Gone with the Wind' and Dan Brown as accomplished a writer as Tolkien. And this is when the critics usually come in - to decide the difference between what is worthwhile creative output and what is worthless, albeit popular, tat. But sometimes it doesn’t matter. If you like Michael Jackson, the fact that I’m not too fussed is unlikely to worry you much. Writing about pop music clearly has a role in these times of ever expanding release schedules - especially as the internet has removed yet another barrier to the entirely talent-free occupying that vital space near our ear drums. But its most interesting moments tend to be when they get it wrong, or when - against the odds - they get something extra-specially right. The enduring appeal of albums the public at large never warmed to, like ‘Forever Changes’, ‘Loveless’ and ‘Doolittle’ show the value of critics. The enduring appeal of ‘Thriller’, an album this particular critic has never heard and probably never will, shows the process’ limitations. So was Michael Jackson any good? To answer that, I suppose I’d have to listen to the records. I’d still rather not.
Also In Condemned to Rock 'n' Roll
Miscellaneous (2015)
Miscellaneous (2015)
Miscellaneous (2015)
Miscellaneous (2015)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2014)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2013)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2012)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2011)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2010)
Miscellaneous (2009)
Miscellaneous (2009)
Miscellaneous (2009)
Miscellaneous (2009)
Miscellaneous (2009)
Miscellaneous (2009)
Miscellaneous (2009)
Miscellaneous (2009)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2008)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2007)
Miscellaneous (2006)
Miscellaneous (2006)
Miscellaneous (2006)
Miscellaneous (2006)
Miscellaneous (2006)
Miscellaneous (2006)
Miscellaneous (2006)
Miscellaneous (2006)
Miscellaneous (2006)
most viewed articles
current edition
John McKay - InterviewRobert Forster - Interview
Cathode Ray - Interview
Spear Of Destiny - Interview
Fiona Hutchings - Interview
When Rivers Meet - Waterfront, Norwich, 29/5/2025
Carl Ewens - David Bowie 1964 to 1982 On Track: Every Album, Every Song
Chris Wade - Interview
Brian Wilson - Ten Songs That Made Me Love...
Shrag - Huw Stephens Session 08.12.10 and Marc Riley Session 21.03.12
previous editions
Heavenly - P.U.N.K. Girl EPBoomtown Rats - Ten Songs That Made Me Love....
Allan Clarke - Interview
Oasis - Oasis, Earl's Court, London, 1995
Manic Street Preachers - (Gig of a Lifetime) Millennium Stadium, Cardiff, December 1999
Barrie Barlow - Interview
Pixies - Ten Songs That Made Me Love...
Beautiful South - Ten Songs That Made Me Love...
Trudie Myerscough-Harris - Interview
Dwina Gibb - Interview
most viewed reviews
current edition
Peter Doolan - I Am a Tree Rooted to the Spot and a Snake Moves Around Me,in a CircleGarbage - Let All That We Imagine Be The Light
Vinny Peculiar - Things Too Long Left Unsaid
Vultures - Liz Kershaw Session 16.06.88
John McKay - Sixes and #Sevens
Little Simz - Lotus
HAIM - I Quit
Morcheeba - Escape The Chaos
Pulp - More
Lapsley - I'm a Hurricane, I'm a Woman In Love
Pennyblackmusic Regular Contributors
Adrian Janes
Amanda J. Window
Andrew Twambley
Anthony Dhanendran
Benjamin Howarth
Cila Warncke
Daniel Cressey
Darren Aston
Dastardly
Dave Goodwin
Denzil Watson
Dominic B. Simpson
Eoghan Lyng
Fiona Hutchings
Harry Sherriff
Helen Tipping
Jamie Rowland
John Clarkson
Julie Cruickshank
Kimberly Bright
Lisa Torem
Maarten Schiethart