Brit Floyd - Bridgewater Hall, Manchester, 2/122014
by Nicky Crewe
published: 8 / 12 / 2014

intro
Nicky Crewe is impressed by Pink Floyd tribute band Brit Floyd's technical and musical brilliance, but is unconvinced by a show at the Bridgewater Hall in Manchester on their latest Discovery tour
I am still coming to terms with the concept of tribute bands. I believe that good music should be played live to audiences, reviving its creative energy. No-one expects to hear classical music played by the composer. It’s about fresh interpretation and new identification. There are covers bands, West End theatre shows, films and tribute bands to share other musicians’ work. Occasionally an artist or band does a definitive version of someone else’s song. There are so many different ways to listen to your favourite artist’s music. So before I go any further in my musings about tribute bands, I have to tell you that Brit Floyd’s Discovery show is fantastic. The musicians are brilliant, the singers are stunning and the staging of the Discovery show is wonderful. The set list takes you back and forth in time through Pink Floyd’s extensive catalogue. Many of the old favourites and a few surprises were included. The lasers, lights and visuals are informative and at times breathtaking. As a tribute band they obviously have a great following, with standing ovations and a huge merchandising stand with queues. The band does a meet and greet signing session after the show too. The band doesn’t attempt to look like members of Pink Floyd. There’s no physical identification that I could see. And, of course, Pink Floyd have their own complicated history of disagreements and reconciliations. If you are trying to cover over forty years of music, it is difficult to choose a particular time and image, let alone line up. For me this was a parallel version of Pink Floyd. If they had been a stadium rock band this might have been how they would appear in a parallel universe. There was a flashiness and virtuosity in the performances which for me was out of keeping with the restraint and psychedelic subtlety of the original music. It was impressive, but it made me nostalgic for something else. So, instead of feeling satisfied with an evening of Pink Floyd music and an inspired stage show, I came out longing for a lost Pink Floyd. I wished I had seen them with Syd. I yearned to have been one of those hippy dancing girls at the UFO club. I wanted a home made trippy light show, not lasers. It brought out overwhelming nostalgia in me. I can still remember a top deck of the bus conversation with school friends about a new single we had heard, ‘Arnold Layne’. I was privileged to have seen Pink Floyd play an early version of ‘Atom Heart Mother’ at the Bath Festival in 1970. ‘The Madcap Laughs’ was the soundtrack to my Saturdays working in a hippy emporium. When I was a teenager, living in Borneo, I had a friend who used to put ‘Interstellar Overdrive’ on full volume in his house so I could hear it in mine. Those sounds filtered through a jungle garden seemed the essence of the surreal nature of Pink Floyd’s music. The lyrics to ‘The Wall’ were often quoted to me by students when I was teaching English abroad, a piece of culture shared in unexpected places. I went to the concert with a friend who has a similarly long history with Pink Floyd. We both wondered whether the audience were fans of Pink Floyd, or fans of Brit Floyd. When a tribute band takes on an identity, they have to interpret it in their own way. They can’t recreate the life experiences and creative processes that took the original musicians to where they found themselves. And as talented musicians in their own right, they have to take their interpretation somewhere else in turn. I wondered if I was too old to appreciate this version of a tribute. There was too much missing for me. I don’t want to undermine the show and the musicians. Take a look at them on YouTube. It is a musically and technically amazing show. But I don’t think I will be reviewing a tribute band again.
Also at Bridgewater Hall, Manchester
Picture Gallery:-


most viewed articles
current edition
Spear Of Destiny - InterviewRobert Forster - Interview
Fiona Hutchings - Interview
When Rivers Meet - Waterfront, Norwich, 29/5/2025
Carl Ewens - David Bowie 1964 to 1982 On Track: Every Album, Every Song
Brian Wilson - Ten Songs That Made Me Love...
Chris Wade - Interview
Pistol Daisys - Waterfront, Norwich, 29/5/2025
Credits - ARC, Liverpool, 17/5.2025
Gary Numan - Berserker
previous editions
Heavenly - P.U.N.K. Girl EPBoomtown Rats - Ten Songs That Made Me Love....
Barrie Barlow - Interview
Manic Street Preachers - (Gig of a Lifetime) Millennium Stadium, Cardiff, December 1999
Oasis - Oasis, Earl's Court, London, 1995
Dwina Gibb - Interview
Pixies - Ten Songs That Made Me Love...
David Paton - Magic: The David Paton Story
Chuck Prophet - Ten Songs That Made Me Love...
Sound - Interview with Bi Marshall Part 1
most viewed reviews
current edition
Peter Doolan - I Am a Tree Rooted to the Spot and a Snake Moves Around Me,in a CircleGarbage - Let All That We Imagine Be The Light
Vinny Peculiar - Things Too Long Left Unsaid
Little Simz - Lotus
John McKay - Sixes and #Sevens
Suzanne Vega - Flying With Angels
HAIM - I Quit
Morcheeba - Escape The Chaos
Vultures - Liz Kershaw Session 16.06.88
Billy Nomates - Metalhorse
Pennyblackmusic Regular Contributors
Adrian Janes
Amanda J. Window
Andrew Twambley
Anthony Dhanendran
Benjamin Howarth
Cila Warncke
Daniel Cressey
Darren Aston
Dastardly
Dave Goodwin
Denzil Watson
Dominic B. Simpson
Eoghan Lyng
Fiona Hutchings
Harry Sherriff
Helen Tipping
Jamie Rowland
John Clarkson
Julie Cruickshank
Kimberly Bright
Lisa Torem
Maarten Schiethart