Dashboard Confessional - The Shade of Poison Trees
by Jonjo McNeill
published: 10 / 10 / 2007

Label:
Vagrant
Format: CD
intro
Stripped down, but powerful fourth album from Dashboard Confessional, which finds frontman Chris Carebba rejecting the overly polished sound of the recent past, and going back to his acoustic roots making a return to form
Two bars into the new Dashboard Confessional record and I’m smiling. Gone are the shiny electric guitars and overly polished sound of their previous effort (the good-but-not-great ‘Dusk And Summer’) and back comes the stripped down acoustic stylings of Chris Carabba’s early work. Harking back to his finest hours (‘The Places You Have Come To Fear The Most’ is, for my money, one of the albums of the decade), Carabba shows that, four albums in, he’s still the tortured poet he started out as, his words still as loaded with emotion as ever, his voice still sounding like it bypassed his mouth and came straight from his heart. It becomes obvious fairly early on somebody has left a bad taste in Carabba’s mouth. ‘Where There’s Gold’ tells of a mistress being left behind by her lover, exploring a side of a situation usually ignored in favour of judgmental bad-mouthing in a sensitive, heartfelt way. ‘Keep Watch For The Mines’ wouldn’t sound out of place on the first Dashboard record (‘Swiss Army Romance’), a staccating acoustic guitar providing the backdrop to an acrobatic vocal which warns of backstabbers and gravediggers. The symbolism used throughout is a trademark of Carabba, and his lyrics are always as loaded with meaning as they appear straightforward. A complicated fella from the start, it’s good to hear him in such fine voice, and still finding the inspiration to make music as emotional as this after the success he’s experienced. ‘Fever Dreams’ marries the acoustic guitars to a synthetic drumkit to fine effect, adding a new dynamic to the sound without abandoning the basic principles of it. As a song it’s possibly the most commercial sounding track on here with its soft harmonies and lyrical hook ("Fever dreams can only haunt you / ‘til the fever breaks"). The title track is the beautiful centrepiece of the album, a synth-touched lament to time lost and chances forgone. I’d put this one up there with ‘Hands Down’ and ‘Screaming Infedilities’ as one of Dashboard oinfessional’s greatest moments. ‘The Rush’ has a sound of it’s own, brushed acoustics building over a rumbling drum line and a low pitch vocal, before a classic Dashboard chorus lifts us as Carabba declares "I’ll know I’m alive". Carabba’s emotions seem to stem from hurt a lot of the time, and how he addresses this hurt determines the sound of his songs. ‘Little Bombs’ is acidic in it’s attack – "I’ve heard enough of your forked tongue / How do you know when the cuts are deep enough ?" and uncompromising in it’s warning "You ought to know better / Than to bait your jailor". It’s a highlight of the record, recalling ‘Saints And Sailors’ from ‘The Places You Have Come To Fear The Most’. The record ends on ‘The Widows Peak’, which starts off piano ballad and ends up sky-scraping anthem. One of Carabba’s best ever vocals perfectly articulating the determination of two lovers to be strong when it’s hard to be strong. Moving and melodic? Why not? I really should stop talking about Dashboard Confessional as if it’s just one man, as that isn’t the case anymore. But understand that the reason I do is because this is a true return to form, revisiting old ground whilst always treading new. Carabba’s songwriting is as strong as ever, and ‘The Shade Of Poison Trees’ will I’m sure be looked on as, if not his finest, then certainly one of his best pieces of work. Like every Dashboard Confessional record there is so much to take out of it. An album truly worth investing your time and emotion in. And one that this reviewer is still smiling about.
Track Listing:-
1 Where There's Gold2 Thick as Thieves
3 Keep Watch for the Mines
4 These Bones
5 Fever Dreams
6 The Shade of Poison Trees
7 The Rush
8 Little Bombs
9 I Light My Own Fires Now
10 Matters of Blood and Connection
11 Clean Breaks
12 The Widow's Peak
Visitor Comments:- |
17142 Posted By: tgkoknae, Russia on 30 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17141 Posted By: tuhbeitle, Zambia on 30 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17136 Posted By: steelersfanblike, China on 30 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17135 Posted By: RobertMut, South Africa on 30 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17134 Posted By: DJDox, Russia on 30 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17133 Posted By: Davidrek, Mali on 30 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17121 Posted By: RudolphFub, Tajikistan on 29 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17111 Posted By: Michaeldef, Papua New Guinea on 29 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17109 Posted By: GeorgePoxow, Poland on 28 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17106 Posted By: Willieduali, Qatar on 28 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17105 Posted By: Robicc, Peru on 28 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17104 Posted By: oknaekbo, Russia on 28 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17101 Posted By: Anya120pt, Island on 28 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17096 Posted By: BrianPione, Canada on 28 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17095 Posted By: Carrolbpf, Turkmenistan on 28 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17093 Posted By: GidiGam, Turkey on 27 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17092 Posted By: LavillDum, United States on 27 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17084 Posted By: DonaldKaf, Nigeria on 27 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17083 Posted By: Harrykiz, Indonesia on 27 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17078 Posted By: Billyplaks, Malaysia on 27 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17077 Posted By: Timothyhaw, Norfolk Island on 27 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17076 Posted By: Carrolayq, United States on 27 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17073 Posted By: ozMag, Russia on 26 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17072 Posted By: LouisKnona, Romania on 26 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17069 Posted By: RudolphTaUby, Australia on 26 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17064 Posted By: RayfordDiash, Argentina on 26 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17063 Posted By: Sanisweby, Belarus on 26 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17062 Posted By: HarryKilia, Costa Rica on 26 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17061 Posted By: RogerPrind, Georgia on 26 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17056 Posted By: Sofahup, Cameroon on 25 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17054 Posted By: onawuzicasw, Slovenia on 25 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17052 Posted By: Leonarddrina, Malaysia on 25 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17050 Posted By: Anya120pt, Island on 25 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17041 Posted By: steelersfanblike, China on 24 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17031 Posted By: AdonyRok, Burma on 24 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17028 Posted By: Travisduh, Lebanon on 23 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17026 Posted By: Robertbic, USA on 23 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17024 Posted By: SteveOnema, Sweden on 23 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17023 Posted By: Brianguica, Cape Verde on 23 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17022 Posted By: StevenSAw, Guyana on 23 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17021 Posted By: Georgetom, Japan on 23 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17020 Posted By: Richardhoons, Yugoslavia on 23 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17011 Posted By: krnkcc, Egypt on 22 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17007 Posted By: Mehr zum Thema, Russia on 22 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17006 Posted By: Normandlon, Singapore on 22 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
17002 Posted By: DenniLof, Slovakia on 21 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
16995 Posted By: Jesseunlib, Romania on 21 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
16994 Posted By: Georgerelry, Chile on 21 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
16992 Posted By: misterdick.ru, Ukraine on 21 Jun 2025 edit |
Thank you - your comment will be published once it has been reviewed
|
interviews |
Interview (2007) |
![]() |
Starting as a solo project for Chris Carabba and soon expanding into a full-band, Dashboard Confessional have just released their fourth album, 'The Shade of Poison Trees'. Jonjo McNeill speaks to Chris Carabba about his decision to return to his acoustic roots with it. |
favourite album |
The Places You Have Come To Fear The Most (2004) |
![]() |
An odd encounter with a Vagrant records sampler plunged Jonjo McNeill into the beginning of a love affair with emo group Dashboard Confessional. He writes about the hold the band's second album 'The Places You Have Come To Fear The Most' has on him |
features |
Dashboard Confessional (2006) |
![]() |
American acoustic/electric guitar emo outfit Dashboard Confessional have recently released their fourth album,the Daniel Lanois-produced 'Dusk and Summer'. Anna Gudaniec photographs them at a lunchtime fan club gig at the Borderline in London |
reviews |
Mark A Mission A Brand A Scar (2003) |
![]() |
"Stunning and affecting" third album, which finds Dashboard Confessional ", marking a move away from the simple acoustic emo of previous records...and towards a fuller, more upbeat sound" |
So Impossible (2003) |
most viewed articles
current edition
Peter Doherty - Blackheath Halls, Blackheath and Palace Halls, Watford, 18/3/2025 and 21/3/2025Armory Show - Interview with Richard Jobson
Liz Mitchell - Interview
Deb Googe and Cara Tivey - Interview
Lauren Mayberry - Photoscapes
Max Bianco and the BlueHearts - Troubadour, London, 29/3/2025
Maarten Schiethart - Vinyl Stories
Sukie Smith - Interview
Clive Langer - Interview
Kim Wilde - Photoscapes
most viewed reviews
current edition
Davey Woodward - Mumbo in the JumboNigel Stonier - Wolf Notes
Wings - Venus and Mars
Only Child - Holy Ghosts
Kate Daisy Grant and Nick Pynn - Songs For The Trees
Neil Campbell - The Turnaround
Philip Jeays - Victoria
Darkness - Dreams On Toast
Suzanne Vega - Flying With Angels
Charles Ellsworth - Cosmic Cannon Fodder
Pennyblackmusic Regular Contributors
Adrian Janes
Amanda J. Window
Andrew Twambley
Anthony Dhanendran
Benjamin Howarth
Cila Warncke
Daniel Cressey
Darren Aston
Dastardly
Dave Goodwin
Denzil Watson
Dominic B. Simpson
Eoghan Lyng
Fiona Hutchings
Harry Sherriff
Helen Tipping
Jamie Rowland
John Clarkson
Julie Cruickshank
Kimberly Bright
Lisa Torem
Maarten Schiethart