Stone Ghost Collective - Unrequited Lovesongs
by Andy Cassidy
published: 11 / 9 / 2011

Label:
Shark Batter Records
Format: CD
intro
Superbly eccentric and unpredictable, yet also inconsistent collection of anti-love songs from Scottish duo, the Stone Ghost Collective
“She doesn’t care if she leaves me with nothing.” The opening line of 'Unrequited Lovesongs' sets the lyrical mood for the entire album, a mood of loss, despair and heartache. That is not to say, however, that the album is not enjoyable or even uplifting –I’m sure I won’t be alone in finding a dark humour in some of the songs. Mike Sorensen Small and Brendan McAndrew have crafted melodious, inventive slices of pop, musically upbeat and quirky, and set them in the context of an album of “anti-love” songs. The harpsichord introduction of 'She Doesn’t Care' provides a suitably gloomy atmosphere, closely followed by a heavily treated vocal, reciting a list of complaints against an unspecified lover. The verse gives way to a superbly juxtaposed bridge – melancholic lyrics sung exuberantly over an MGMT-style electronic riff. Lyrically, Brendan McAndrew reminds me of Loudon Wainwright III in the way he writes about dysfunctional relationships; yes, there is sadness, but there is also a wry resignation which leads to some particularly humorous lyrics. Track two, for instance, describes the object of spurned affection thus: “The Little Cleaver of my heart/She is holding me apart.” There are touches of real style throughout the album; the doom-laden bell on 'Steppenstone', the heart-wrenching strings on 'The Saddest Truth', the vocal harmonies on 'Another Today'. Musically and thematically, the album has a great deal in common with the Magnetic Fields’ '69 Love Songs', and, in my opinion, both albums suffer from the same problem: quite simply, with so many musical styles on display, ranging from the profound to the borderline flippant, it is difficult to take the album seriously. 'Lament', for instance, talks of “youth’s intense uncertainty” and patience breaking “free from its bonds,” while the following song, 'Miles of Bedroom', begins with a chirpy vocal announcing “There’s a ghost in my loving machine.” Musically Stone Ghost Collective have been compared to the Beach Boys and I can understand why – like the Beach Boys’ immediate post-'SMiLE!' material, the SGC’s songs are superbly eccentric and unpredictable. In fact, the term Baroque Pop could have been coined for them. 'Unrequited Lovesongs' is an album of thirteen very good songs, but the inconsistency of mood somehow reinforces the conclusion that the album is less than the sum of its parts. It is, however, an album that I will go back to and enjoy again, and I will be extremely keen to hear what Stone Ghost Collective come up with next. Maybe some of that love is requited after all…
Track Listing:-
1 She Doesn't Care2 Little Cleaver
3 Steppenstone
4 Lost Cause
5 Why
6 Perfumed Letter Bomb
7 The Saddest Truth
8 Crystal Clear
9 Romantic Love Is A Vicious Lie
10 Another Today
11 Lament
12 Miles Of Bedroom
13 Moonlight Cantata
Label Links:-
http://www.sharkbatter.com/https://twitter.com/sharkbatter
https://www.reverbnation.com/label/sharkbatterrecords
most viewed articles
current edition
Peter Doherty - Blackheath Halls, Blackheath and Palace Halls, Watford, 18/3/2025 and 21/3/2025Armory Show - Interview with Richard Jobson
Liz Mitchell - Interview
Lauren Mayberry - Photoscapes
Deb Googe and Cara Tivey - Interview
Max Bianco and the BlueHearts - Troubadour, London, 29/3/2025
Garfunkel and Garfunkel Jr. - Interview
Maarten Schiethart - Vinyl Stories
Clive Langer - Interview
Kim Wilde - Photoscapes
most viewed reviews
current edition
Davey Woodward - Mumbo in the JumboNigel Stonier - Wolf Notes
Wings - Venus and Mars
Kate Daisy Grant and Nick Pynn - Songs For The Trees
Only Child - Holy Ghosts
Neil Campbell - The Turnaround
Philip Jeays - Victoria
Darkness - Dreams On Toast
Suzanne Vega - Flying With Angels
Charles Ellsworth - Cosmic Cannon Fodder
Pennyblackmusic Regular Contributors
Adrian Janes
Amanda J. Window
Andrew Twambley
Anthony Dhanendran
Benjamin Howarth
Cila Warncke
Daniel Cressey
Darren Aston
Dastardly
Dave Goodwin
Denzil Watson
Dominic B. Simpson
Eoghan Lyng
Fiona Hutchings
Harry Sherriff
Helen Tipping
Jamie Rowland
John Clarkson
Julie Cruickshank
Kimberly Bright
Lisa Torem
Maarten Schiethart