Manchester Orchestra - Mean Everything to Nothing
by Chris O'Toole
published: 11 / 9 / 2009

Label:
Favorite Gentlemen
Format: CD
intro
Cerebral, but surprisingly versatile debut album from Atlanta-based group the Manchester Orchestra, which will come as a welcome treat to punk metal fans
To say the path is well trodden would be to criminally underestimate the situation. Manchester Orchestra's biography reads like a carbon copy of countless American bands. Growing up in the suburbs, in this case the suburbs of Atlanta, Georgia, a group of young men become disillusioned with life and channel their energy into music. Lacking the imagination to break out from the prevailing modus operandi they are swept along in the coattails of consensus, achieving moderate success. 'Mean Everything to Nothing' is a case in point, with Manchester Orchestra operating as heirs to Alkaline Trio, with the yelps of frontman/songwriter Andy Hull almost chemically designed to imitate Matt Skiba, or an early Weakerthans. The album's 11 tracks trundle past; part homage, part pastiche. And yet, and yet in this case it seems to actually work. The depth of Hull's song writing belies the group's youth – tackling subjects outside of the normal youth alienation, disenfranchisement and redemption through love. Despite relentless touring, including appearances at Lollapalooza, the group maintain a fresh, vigorous outlook. The group is almost naively optimistic; quietly assuming that if they riff loud enough the arenas will simply be built around them. While there are too many bands plying this rock with a faux cerebral edge for them all to make it, 'Pride' and 'Shake it Out' are worth the space on the iPod, while the slower '100 Dollars' illustrate a versatility and song craft lacking from some so-called emo contenders. For those interested in the genre this will be a welcome treat, while for outsiders 'Mean Everything to Nothing' will blur seamlessly into the background.
Track Listing:-
1 The Only One2 Shake It Out
3 I've Got Friends
4 Pride
5 In My Teeth
6 100 Doller
7 I Can Feel A Hot One
8 My Friend Marcus
9 Tony The Tiger
10 Everything To Nothing
11 The River
12 Jimmy, He Whispers
Band Links:-
https://twitter.com/manchesterorchhttp://themanchesterorchestra.com/
https://www.facebook.com/ManchesterOrchestra/
soundcloud
reviews |
Cope (2014) |
![]() |
Slow-burning, but heartfelt and thoughtful fourth album from the much acclaimed Manchester Orchestra |
Shake It Out (2009) |
I'm Like a Virgin Losing a Child (2007) |
most viewed articles
current edition
Yardbirds - Interview with Jim McCartyPeter Doherty - Blackheath Halls, Blackheath and Palace Halls, Watford, 18/3/2025 and 21/3/2025
Johnny Cash - Video Vault
John Philip Shenale - Interview
Max Bianco and the BlueHearts - Troubadour, London, 29/3/2025
Armory Show - Interview with Richard Jobson
Deb Googe and Cara Tivey - Interview
Vapors - Interview
Loft - Interview
Waeve - Club Academy, Manchester, 18/3/2025
most viewed reviews
current edition
Bryan Ferry and Amelia Barrett - Loose TalkIvor Game - When Will You Fall Into My Loving Arms?
Gabriel Moreno - Nights in the Belly of Bohemia
Doris Brendel and Lee Dunham - Big Blue Sky
Bryan Adams - Live at the Royal Albert Hall 2024
Brooke Combe - Dancing at the Edge of the World
Shaw's Trailer Park - I Thought I Saw You
Ringo Starr - Look Up
Leon Bridges - Leon
FKA twigs - Eusexua
Pennyblackmusic Regular Contributors
Adrian Janes
Amanda J. Window
Andrew Twambley
Anthony Dhanendran
Benjamin Howarth
Cila Warncke
Daniel Cressey
Darren Aston
Dastardly
Dave Goodwin
Denzil Watson
Dominic B. Simpson
Eoghan Lyng
Fiona Hutchings
Harry Sherriff
Helen Tipping
Jamie Rowland
John Clarkson
Julie Cruickshank
Kimberly Bright
Lisa Torem
Maarten Schiethart